So, the final five American Idols sings songs of Neil Diamond...boring, right?  Of course, my fave David Cook was awesome, as was Syesha.   Jason and Brooke were painful and Archie, was, well, Archie.   Ryan was annoying as usual...I even heard that Idol may be "testing" to see how if Seacrest is to blame for falling ratings.  Dude does have too many irons in the fire, no wonder he's grumpy all the time.   Anywho, what was Paula smoking?   The kids were singing two songs each and Paula, Randy and Simon were supposed to wait til after BOTH songs to critique.   Then, Ryan throws them a curve ball, and lines up the five after performance number one for a "quick comment."    Check out what happens next...

http://www.tmz.com/tmz_main_video?titleid=1529520166

Poor girl, got all confused....so who goes home?   I wouldn't be sad at all if it were anyone but David Cook....Archie maybe?  Not yet.  Should be Jason or Brooke.   We'll see...

---Nancy